Travelers vs Progressive: which is better? Comparison 2026
By our public methodology Travelers scores 72 out of 100 and Progressive scores 67. Below: the factors and facts where they differ, each fact with its source.
Score breakdown
| Travelers | Progressive | |
|---|---|---|
| Reliability | 100 | 75 |
| Service | 57 | 86 |
| Products | 50 | 50 |
| Transparency | 50 | 25 |
Pros and cons
Travelers
- Long track record as a licensed insurer
- Holds a financial strength rating from a recognised agency
- Publishes annual financial reports
- Claims can be reported online
Progressive
- Long track record as a licensed insurer
- Publishes annual financial reports
- Policies can be bought online
- Claims can be reported online
Facts side by side
| Fact | Travelers | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| Licensed since | 1864 travelers.com | 1937 progressive.com |
| Buy a policy online | Not verified | Yes progressive.com |
| Rating from a rating agency | Yes travelers.com | Not verified |
| Financial reports online | Yes investor.travelers.com | Yes investors.progressive.com |
| Part of a group | Yes travelers.com | Yes s202.q4cdn.com |
| Report a claim online | Yes travelers.com | Yes progressive.com |
| Mobile app | Yes travelers.com | Yes progressive.com |
| 24/7 phone line | Yes travelers.com | Yes progressive.com |
| Retail lines offered (of 6) | 3 travelers.com | 3 progressive.com |
| Complaints procedure published | Yes travelers.com | Not verified |
| Calculator or tariffs | Yes travelers.com | Yes progressive.com |