Progressive vs Amica: which is better? Comparison 2026

By our public methodology Progressive scores 67 out of 100 and Amica scores 66. Below: the factors and facts where they differ, each fact with its source.

Insurance companies in the US 2026: a ranking built on verified facts How we rank

2

Progressive

67/100
3

Amica

66/100

Score breakdown

ProgressiveAmica
Reliability7588
Service8657
Products5067
Transparency2525

Pros and cons

Progressive

  • Long track record as a licensed insurer
  • Publishes annual financial reports
  • Policies can be bought online
  • Claims can be reported online

Amica

  • Long track record as a licensed insurer
  • Holds a financial strength rating from a recognised agency
  • Publishes annual financial reports
  • Claims can be reported online

Facts side by side

FactProgressiveAmica
Licensed since1937 progressive.com1907 amica.com
Buy a policy onlineYes progressive.comNot verified
Rating from a rating agencyNot verifiedYes amica.com
Financial reports onlineYes investors.progressive.comYes amica.com
Part of a groupYes s202.q4cdn.comNo amica.com
Report a claim onlineYes progressive.comYes amica.com
Mobile appYes progressive.comYes amica.com
24/7 phone lineYes progressive.comYes amica.com
Retail lines offered (of 6)3 progressive.com4 amica.com
Calculator or tariffsYes progressive.comYes amica.com

← Insurance companies